Screen Printing vs Sublimation: What to Choose

When you’re considering custom printing—whether it’s for t-shirts, mugs, or promotional items—screen printing and sublimation are two of the most popular techniques available. Each has its own advantages depending on your design, material, and production goals.

In this guide, we’ll break down both methods, explore their pros and cons, and help you figure out which one is the better fit for your needs.

What is Screen Printing?

Screen printing is a traditional printing method that uses a mesh screen and ink to transfer a design onto a surface. It's one of the oldest and most widely used techniques for custom apparel and promotional products.

The process starts with creating a stencil (or "screen") for each color in the design. Ink is then pushed through the screen onto the fabric or surface using a squeegee. Once the ink is applied, the material is cured using heat or UV light to set the design.

This method is ideal for high-volume orders and bold designs that don’t require too many colors or intricate details.

Types of Inks Used in Screen Printing

There are several kinds of inks used in screen printing, each with its own look and feel:

• Plastisol ink is thick, vibrant, and sits on top of the fabric. It’s commonly used for bright, long-lasting prints.

• Water-based ink soaks into the fabric, giving a softer, more breathable feel, and is often preferred for eco-conscious printing.
  Discharge ink removes the fabric dye and replaces it with a new color, resulting in a soft and natural-looking print—especially on darker garments.

Best Materials for Screen Printing

Screen printing is versatile in terms of the surfaces it can be applied to. It works best on:

• 100% cotton (the gold standard)
• Cotton/polyester blends
• Polyester (with caution, due to potential dye migration)
• Non-fabric items like paper, glass, wood, and plastic

Because screen printing lays ink on top of the material, it can be used effectively on both light and dark-colored fabrics.

What is Sublimation?

Sublimation is a modern digital printing technique that uses heat to transfer dye into the fabric rather than on top of it. Unlike screen printing, there’s no stencil or layering of ink—everything is done digitally.

The process begins by printing a design onto special sublimation transfer paper using sublimation inks. The design is then placed onto the material and heat-pressed. The heat turns the ink into gas, which then bonds directly with the polyester fibers.

This method results in a permanent, vibrant print that won’t fade, crack, or peel over time. It becomes part of the fabric, rather than sitting on top of it.

What Materials Can You Sublimate?

Sublimation only works on polyester or polymer-coated surfaces. It's not suitable for cotton or dark-colored fabrics because the dye bonds with polyester fibers and is transparent by nature.

You can use sublimation on:

• White or light-colored polyester t-shirts and apparel
  
• Mugs, phone cases, mousepads, coasters (must be specially coated)
  
• Sublimation-ready aluminum or hardboard panels for photo printing
  

Sublimation Ink Types

• Aqueous sublimation ink is most common for desktop printers and is water-based.
  
• Solvent-based sublimation ink is used in commercial setups and offers greater durability.

Screen Printing vs Sublimation: A Detailed Comparison

Let’s take a closer look at how these two techniques differ in real-world usage.

Process & Application

• Screen Printing: Uses stencils/screens to apply layers of ink to a surface. Great for bold, graphic designs and high-volume runs.
  

• Sublimation: Transfers dye into the material using heat. Best for detailed, full-color designs and individual customization.
  

Material Compatibility

Screen printing is flexible with materials and can be used on:

• Cotton
• Blends
• Paper, glass, plastic, and more

Sublimation, however, is limited to:

• Polyester garments
• Polymer-coated hard surfaces

Color & Design Capabilities

• Screen printing excels at solid colors but struggles with photo-realistic images or gradients.
  

• Sublimation allows for unlimited color combinations, gradients, and highly detailed images without affecting the feel of the fabric.
  
  

Durability

Both methods are durable, but in different ways:

• Screen prints can last for years, especially when properly cured. However, they might crack or fade over time, particularly with heat exposure or rough washing.
  

• Sublimation prints are embedded into the fabric and won’t peel, crack, or fade—making them ideal for activewear and items that go through frequent washing.
  
  

Feel on Fabric

• Screen prints can be felt on the surface, especially with thick plastisol ink.
  

• Sublimation designs have no texture—they feel just like the fabric itself.
  
  

Cost, Efficiency, and Production Volume

The cost-efficiency of each method depends on the size and scope of your project.

• Screen printing has higher setup costs due to screen creation, especially for multi-color designs. However, once set up, it’s very cost-effective for large batches.
  

• Sublimation has minimal setup, making it ideal for one-off prints or short runs. Each item can have a different design at no extra setup cost.

If you're printing 100+ shirts with the same logo, screen printing is usually more economical. If you're customizing just a few items with intricate or full-color artwork, sublimation is the better option.

Environmental Considerations

Sustainability is an important factor for many businesses today.

• Screen printing can produce waste in the form of excess ink, screen-cleaning chemicals, and water usage. However, water-based inks are a more eco-friendly alternative.
  

• Sublimation produces less waste overall and uses water-based inks, making it the greener option—especially for smaller-scale production.
  
  

Kickstart your creative projects with Caydo’s all-in-one screen printing kits—perfect for beginners and pros alike. Shop now and get everything you need to create vibrant, custom prints from the comfort of your home.

Screen Printing or Sublimation: Which One Should You Choose?

Choosing between the two methods depends on your specific needs:

Choose Screen Printing if you:

• Are printing on cotton or dark-colored fabrics

• Need large quantities of the same design

• Are working with bold, graphic-heavy artwork

• Want long-lasting prints for promotional materials or uniforms

Choose Sublimation if you:

• Need highly detailed, photo-quality prints

• Are working with polyester or coated items

• Want to create custom one-off items (like personalized gifts)

• Are printing on white or light-colored fabrics

Final Thoughts

Both screen printing and sublimation have their place in the world of custom printing. The best choice depends on the type of material, design complexity, budget, and intended use.

• Screen printing is ideal for cotton shirts, bold designs, and high-quantity orders.
  
  

• Sublimation is perfect for detailed graphics, polyester garments, and short-run or personalized items.
  
  

Take time to evaluate your project’s goals, materials, and aesthetic preferences to make the best choice—and your final product will not only look great but last a long time.

Frequently Asked Questions

When deciding between screen printing and sublimation, it's crucial to consider factors like durability, cost, print quality, and material compatibility. Each method has its strengths and limitations.

Which printing method is more durable, screen printing or sublimation?

Screen printing is known for its durability, especially on cotton fabrics. The ink sits on top of the fabric, creating a thick layer. Sublimation, on the other hand, becomes part of the fabric, making it less prone to fading or cracking on polyester items.

How does the cost of screen printing compare with sublimation?

Screen printing often has lower costs for large orders due to economies of scale. Initial setup involves creating screens, which is costlier for small batches. Sublimation costs remain consistent since it doesn't require screens, making it more economical for smaller runs.

In terms of print quality, which is superior between screen printing and sublimation?

Sublimation excels in detail and vibrancy, as it embeds dye directly into the fabric. This makes it ideal for full-color designs. Screen printing can achieve high-quality results, but it's better suited for simpler designs with fewer colors.

What are the material limitations when choosing between sublimation and screen printing?

Screen printing works well on a wide variety of materials, including cotton, polyester, and blends. Sublimation, however, requires polyester or polymer-coated substrates. This limits its use to mainly polyester fabrics, which are necessary for the dye to bond effectively.